An employer that receives a request for accommodation has to work on it in good faith, and it cannot stall a worker into giving up. In Strife v. Aldine Independent School District, the Fifth Circuit let a combat veteran’s failure-to-accommodate claim go forward even though her employer approved her request in the end. The ruling reaches any Texas worker who has waited months for an answer, and any worker who finally got a yes and wonders whether the wait still counts.
You asked. You sent the letter from your doctor, and Human Resources said it needed more. You sent more, and it wanted a different kind of doctor. Then it wanted its own. Weeks became months. Nobody told you no. Nobody told you yes. And every morning you went to work without the thing you asked for.
The federal appeals court that covers Texas has held that an employer that drags out a request like that can violate the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). It can do so even when it says yes at the end.
Weeks of maybe
Alisha Strife served in Iraq and came home with injuries to her brain, shoulder, and leg, and with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). By 2022 she worked in Human Resources for the Aldine Independent School District, north of Houston. She asked for one thing. She wanted her certified service dog with her at work. The district did not have to buy anything or build anything.
The district kept asking. Her provider at the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) wrote a letter, and the district wanted a medical doctor. Her psychiatrist wrote one, and the district wanted its own physician to examine her. Two more doctors confirmed she needed the dog at work, and the district wanted their notes. She sent the notes, and the district said they did not address other options. Six months went by.
Strife filed a charge of discrimination and then a lawsuit. A federal judge told both sides to finish the process. Eight days later, the district said yes.
The trial court threw out her claim. She had her dog, the reasoning went, and nothing had happened to her while she waited. The Fifth Circuit reversed in Strife v. Aldine Independent School District, 138 F.4th 237 (5th Cir. 2025).
A yes at the end does not erase the wait
Most workers who finally get their accommodation assume the matter is closed. The court did not see it that way. The district granted Strife’s request, and her claim went forward anyway. The court looked hard at when the yes came. It came after she sued, and a jury could read that timing as a reason to disbelieve the district’s explanation that it simply needed more information.
You do not have to get hurt first
Strife never fell while she waited. She was never demoted. Her pay never changed. The trial court treated that as the end of the case. The Fifth Circuit called it the wrong question. The right one is whether the employer made a reasonable accommodation once it knew what she needed, and a failure-to-accommodate claim does not require a firing, a demotion, or a pay cut.
The court also named what a slow employer does to a worker. The delay “undoubtedly forced Strife to work under suboptimal conditions” for six months. And an employer that drags its feet can watch a worker struggle without the accommodation, document the struggle, and then use it as a reason to let her go. The court refused to let an employer escape the law by putting a worker through “an endless interactive process.”
There is no required stack of paperwork
Strife sent letter after letter. Your case does not have to look like hers. No law sets a number of letters, a type of doctor, or a form a worker must complete before a request counts. Under guidance from the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), a worker can ask in plain words, without naming the ADA or saying “reasonable accommodation.”
An employer may ask for reasonable medical information when the need is not obvious. Once it has enough to understand the limitation and the request, the burden of the delay belongs to the employer. The EEOC has warned that pressing a worker to see the employer’s own doctor after she has already documented her need can be retaliation, and the court in Strife cited that warning. Each demand past that point is a choice to wait.
That matters to veterans. Many document a service-connected disability through the VA, as Strife did. The first letter her district rejected came from her VA provider. A VA record is medical evidence, and an employer that brushes it aside to start the process over owns the months that follow.
Every case turns on its own facts. Strife’s facts are one example of how an employer stalls. They are not a bar every worker has to clear.
The answer was in the waiting
Nobody told you no. Nobody told you yes. But an employer that holds a request open month after month, asking for one more letter each time, has given its answer. The Fifth Circuit has said a jury may hear it. Veterans Day is November 11. Veterans who answered their country’s call without delay should not have to wait on their employer’s.
Jermaine A. Brown is a trial attorney in the Houston office of Wiley Wheeler, P.C., where he represents employees in disability discrimination, failure-to-accommodate, and wrongful termination cases. He earned his law degree from the University of Houston Law Center and an MBA from Frostburg State University, and he uses that understanding of how organizations operate to help clients challenge the decisions made about them. If you asked your employer for an accommodation and are still waiting, or you got a yes only after months of delay, you can schedule a consultation with Jermaine Brown here.







